Talking with Toadvine

The midwest is wrapped in alt-country-rock. Since the days of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, that genre mutation has stretched its wide arms across these plains. When I reached out to Chicago’s Toadvine, it was my goal to persuade them to put on a Twin Cities show. I could see it as soon as I heard their revved up track “Pontoon Boat:” Turf Club filled to its sticky brim, clumsy limbs playing catch up with the keys. The single is one of five from their debut album, Palace, to be released this Friday, Nov. 27th. 

It would take more than two hyphens to define Toadvine. Their discography spans from slinging road trip anthems to angular indie-rock to Lake Michigan tinted tropical. The band is composed of Tristan Huygen, Jesse Cheshire, and Andrew Marczak on guitar and vocals, Trevor Joellenbeck on bass, and Allen Wynn on drums. I caught them for a pre-album-release chat last weekend; check out our conversation below.

Who is Toadvine? 

Tristan: Who are we? The existential reckoning right off the bat. I’ll start by saying how we met, and that’ll lead into a realization of who we are. Me, Andrew, Jesse, and Trevor know each other from living in Ohio. Actually, we came up there. We were playing in bands in that scene, and then in 2019 we moved to Chicago. This project had started out with Jesse and I back when we were still in Ohio, and then we brought in Andrew and Trevor. By the time we got to Chicago, we did some lineup changes, and kept writing and recording a couple EPs. Alan joined in 2023 or 2024.

Andrew: You kept seeing him drum everywhere, and we kind of scouted him.

Tristan: Yeah, we drafted him. Fundamentally, though, the thing that I’ve enjoyed about this band since it started is that it’s incredibly collaborative on purpose and would not exist without that. For me, a big blueprint is a group like The Band or the Beatles, where you have multiple singers and multiple songwriters. I personally really enjoy that. It’s not like a band where there’s one songwriter, and everyone else just plays those songs. The driving force behind [Toadvine] is collaboration. We’re a group of essentially five songwriters. The four of us– me, Jesse, Andrew, and Trevor– bring the songs, and then Alan also writes parts and sings harmonies.

I noticed overlapping songs across your different groups, like “Pontoon Boat” and “Weather.” Are there more tracks from your other projects that will be on the debut?

Andrew: I don’t think we have any other songs like those. I didn’t have many songs for a while, so I brought a different version of songs like “Pontoon Boat.” For the most part, [the debut] has songs that were written for the band.

Tristan: Yeah, and also the tail end of our second EP and the start of the writing for this album coincided in a bunch of different ways. Trevor and I were playing in a different group that disbanded, Jesse and Andrew were playing in a different band that disbanded, Jesse started a band, Andrew started his solo project, and we started the writing for this Toadvine record. The gestation of this album came out of that era.

Do you feel your respective hometowns influence your songwriting or instrumental inspirations?

Jesse: My parents are kind of older; they were not full hippies, but like the tail end of that era. I grew up with a lot of The Band and Bob Dylan, so not fully country. When me and Tristan started we were talking a lot about Graham Parsons and The Byrds, like Sweetheart of the Rodeo. I write songs for Toadvine from that Americana place that I was raised in.

Trevor: I’ve lived in a bunch of different places too, so I couldn’t pinpoint if any one specific place had an influence on the songs I’ve written. I do feel like me, Jesse, Tristan, and Andrew are really good at painting pictures. When I’ve written the songs that I have on this album, I can see a picture; I’m thinking of “Papaya.” I feel like Toadvine does have its own sound, so that if I write a song, I can feel like this is a Toadvine song or this definitely isn’t a Toadvine song. On this record that sound opened up and changed directions a bit, which I thought was really cool. We all brought in songs that weren’t the same thing as before, but it all fell into this new sound. 

Tristan: Yeah, definitely. I also have, like Jesse mentioned, a love for that cosmic American music of Graham Parsons and The Byrds. My whole family’s from the South, so I grew up listening to a lot of Wayne and Jennings, Willie Nelson, The Allman Brothers Band, and all your traditional Southern music. A little more in the traditional country stuff, but also I love the bands of the British Invasion, like the Beatles and The Who and The Stones and all that. We also have a shared affinity for angularity and dissonance; we love Television and post punk bands like Magazine or Wire. Some of that sneaks in too. But I think the throughline is this The Band or Dylan-esque folk. I guess country-rock, folk-rock. Old guy music. Yeah. Music for guys changing their oil.

That I did have a question about. If you could picture the ideal setting to hear the album, like, you were just sitting somewhere and you heard it playing, where would you be?

Tristan: A surprisingly divey bar in a large city. Sometimes, in Chicago, you’ll go to the far north side, and you’ll enter a bar that feels like you’re in an Iowa college town. That sums it up. Spiritually diving, while surrounded by the cacophony of a city. What do you guys think? 

Allen: I think it would be perfect to play at my apartment for all my friends and family. They’ll be so proud of me. This is my first time on vinyl, and I’ve been out in bands for like 100 years. So this is nice. They brought me into the fold. 

Trevor: When Tristan described the bar, I was thinking of the Eagles Club in Minneapolis. I’ve been there, and I’ve been in Eagles Clubs in other cities, and Minneapolis is pretty dope. That would be a great place for this album.

Andrew: Yeah, one of those Eagles or Moose Club, but in the upper, upper peninsula, like freaking Cole Harbor.

What was the production process of this album like? How did it compare to your previous projects?

Tristan: We knew we wanted to make an album because we had done two EPs, and this was the first record with this lineup– Trevor on bass and Alan playing drums. It felt really good, and as a response to that, more songs were coming. We talked a lot about the production of it; we have a studio called Jamdek here in town that we love. We knew we were going to record it there, and we did a lot of rehearsing. We wanted to record all the basic tracks live, and we had a stipulation that we would use our own instruments and amplifiers because we liked the sound we were getting. We did one day of overdubs at the studio and all the vocals. We had these precedents and limitations that we set for ourselves and we were sticking to them. In my opinion, having self-imposed limits can really drive you and keep things organized, especially with a five, sometimes six-person band– we’ll have a pedal steel player sometimes as a sixth. I mix the record, and then we have a mastering engineer that we like to use. 

Jesse: Bouncing off what Tristan said, and because he’s humble, I would say that Tristan’s kind of the brain of the band. Before the recording, we all had ideas. A lot of what made it sound good together is Tristan. He’s got things going on up there. We collaboratively came up with ideas but there was a coaching element at play, we ironed out a lot of the creases in advance so that we could perform without too much pressing around after the fact. A very healthy amount of rehearsing went in before the cutting of the record happened.

Trevor: Toadvine’s recorded multiple times at Jamdek. Orillia’s recorded at Jamdek. I’ve recorded at Jamdek. We are really familiar with that studio and the guy that runs it, Doug Malone, he’s a really talented dude. We also don’t have a ton of resources to spend on many days there. The rehearsal is essential. We’ve gotten pretty good at doing that pre-work and then going in there and knocking it out. I mean we had two or three days there and 12 or 13 songs to record total, and still somehow we had time to find cool things in the moment. A couple of us brought some new songs in the last few months, and we’ve already had a whole practice devoted to a couple of them where we add in little things here and there, and we come away with a few practice recordings. It’s a slow process, but it allows us to be very efficient when it’s time to track.

Tristan: I want to add on that note, we also had in writing and recording this record a good idea of not only how the songs themselves would play but how it would play as a whole. For example: I have two songs on it, Andrew has two songs on it, Trevor has two songs on it, Jesse sings the other four or so. We were thinking about what song was going to end side one and what song would start side two. A big part when we got into the mixing stage was figuring out a way to not only bring all these different songs from different writers together as a band, but to create it into a larger whole. I think sometimes a band with four songwriters and five singers can get real all over the place real quick if you don’t have a larger goal in mind and the ability to curate yourself. Listening straight through this record, it does flow really well. The voices you hear singing lead are dispersed across the record in an even way, there was a lot of thought going into that too.

Allen: This is actually why I do think it would be good to listen to at one’s apartment or in a quiet setting. That’s where I first heard all the albums by Pink Floyd. I feel like it would be good to chill at home with this record. I just want to make sure the thing I said earlier was taken somewhat seriously.

Tristan: To that point, I do think that listening to the record on vinyl is the best way to experience it, hard sell on the vinyl there. We made it for that reason. It’s an old school way of making it, but I just think it sequences really well, and I think you have to do that when you have so many songwriters in a band.

Do you feel like there’s a throughline across the songs on this record?

Jesse: Great question, but disappointing answer: I feel like probably not. Everyone’s on there in a painting-a-picture way. Some of mine might be slightly personal, but when I think about all the songs together, there are moods to each one, more like scenes than confessions. It’s nice if you have a bunch of different people writing. It’s not each person’s problems expressed, which could be a great thing, but not when there are a bunch of different people doing that at the same time. I feel like the songs have some sort of evocative feeling, it’s hard to pinpoint a personal thing that inspired each song.

Andrew: This is not like a theme necessarily either, but since we all write differently, I feel like we have overlapping interests. It feels somewhat collage-y and almost like there’s newspaper clippings from each of our lives that are put into this thing. Maybe the fonts are a little bit different, but it all makes sense together.

Trevor: I would almost say all of the songs have a vibe of storytelling, but it’s not dream-like storytelling where you’re describing something between reality and a dream. I know some of the songs are about an actual event and some of them are written in the same exact way but aren’t about an actual event. I think that’s cool because some tracks remind me of a picture that I would have in a dream, but they have semblances of reality.

Did any of you have a favorite song to write or record?

Trevor: I like the really rocking ones, like “White Tag,” “Pontoon Boat,” and “Tree Crush.” Maybe those are three songs that I use a fuzz on the bass. We’ve played those songs dozens and dozens of times, and still if we hit it just right at the show or in a practice it’s like, “that was fun.” Those are my favorites.

Tristan: I really enjoy recording. There’s a song on the record, not one of the singles, called “Out of Town.” It’s the last song on the record, and it was one of the last songs we did at night, so it was really late. The elements are great. Trevor was playing a fretless bass. There were noise-collage things we were making. Andrew has this piano part that we were running through this crazy tape delay and physically modulating the time and timbre. It was one of those songs that really took shape in the studio because we did a lot of rehearsing and pre-planning. That was a song that we had planned out, but the timbres and the little things that we layered took a life of their own. I always love that, when you’re in a studio and all of the sudden what you’re putting in comes back at you in a way that you didn’t expect.

Andrew:  I like playing the song “Drive.” It’s one of Trevor’s songs and one of the rare ones I play lead guitar on. I think that song goes pretty hard. It’s not quite up-tempo, but it does feel like a rocker.

Trevor: Great music video, too. As a side note, I really appreciate how much work everybody in this group does, and how talented everybody is, even the stuff that we do on our own has turned out super well. We also have a good group of friends that are really talented and willing to help us out. Andrew’s partner did the video for our song “Papaya,” and our friend Matt did the video for “Drive.” Tristan’s friend made a new T-shirt design. We’re often on a budget, but the stuff we’re able to do with that budget is really cool. It’s just fun to be in a group where we’re all doing a part, and then we hear the product, it’s been turning out really well. That’s awesome trust in the power of community. 

What other creative endeavors do you all get up to outside of music?

Tristan: We’re all friends as well as collaborators, which I really like. A lot of us are into the same kind of visual art. Jesse painted our EP cover for the second EP. Andrew does photography and video. Trevor is an amazing woodworker and photographer and also is brilliant– he’s coding our website. We all love movies. We live in the same cultural exchange world, and we enjoy the same kind of art. We’ll show each other stuff or read similar books, or a couple of us will have a thing we’re doing at one time. Jesse and Trevor are neighbors, Andrew and I live close to each other. Alan lives way the hell up on the north side. Sorry, Alan, but we’re always thinking of him. We are lucky in that we’re multidisciplinary, and like Trevor said earlier, that also makes things a lot more cost-effective. We can design our own show posters. We can design our own album covers, and obviously we like to work with other people when we can. But we have the freedom and the control over a lot of the record, the visuals, the presentation, and a lot of that comes from having these shared interests outside of music.

Where did the name Toadvine come from?

Tristan: It’s a name of a character from Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian. 

Andrew: I just finished it today. Required reading. I was about to be kicked out of the band. 

Trevor: Back to the Toadvine book list. It should be assigned reading.

Tristan: It’s the name of a character in that book. We have a lot of country influence, but we’re not purely a country band. We can do that. We’ll play cover gigs for money a lot of times because we can pull out all the old standards. But I wanted a name that spoke to the in-betweens with country music and the darker, more angular, post-punk rock type stuff. Blood Meridian is not a traditional Western book. So I thought, first of all, it’s just a nice name. It’s two syllables. It’s symmetrical, but there was also something to it being from a book that straddles a line between modernity and an idea of what the west is. I think that is a window into how we view our traditional influences and how we view our avant-garde influences. 

I’ve only read The Road, but I would like to believe that this Toadvine character is a good guy.

Tristan: Oh, he’s a bad guy. It’s tough because sometimes when you say it’s from that book– it’s a dark book. He is a very beautifully, strenuously dark writer. 

Andrew: I once left this book on a bar, and the bartender took it off the bar because they didn’t want it to scare people away. The bartender was also my partner, but still.

Tristan: It’s not necessarily about the character in that book, but what the genre that book comes out of is analogous to the way that we approach our country and folk influences. 

That’s a good way to find a name. 

Tristan: Yeah, exactly. There also weren’t too many other people with that band name, so that always helps too. 

What’s next for Toadvine? Do you have any pre-album release plans or shows in the works?

Tristan: The record is called Palace. It comes out on the 27th of November, Black Friday. We have a release show here in Chicago at a place called Schuba’s Tavern on December 3rd. In January we’re playing a show in town, and then we’re playing a little run in St. Louis, Nashville, Birmingham, and then we’re back. That’s our next couple of months. We’ve released all the pre-album singles we’re going to release. There’s going to be a post-album single coming out in January. I’m excited for it. 

Trevor: We’re already working on new songs. The next cycle begins. It’s an ouroboros. I definitely want to do a show in Wisconsin– either Madison or Milwaukee– and then Saint Paul, Minneapolis, maybe Iowa, but those two for sure. I have quite a few friends that are from Minneapolis or Saint Paul and have moved to Chicago. I played up there once and we just played with a band from there [Harlow] in Chicago. It sucks that we haven’t been able to go that route yet. Overdue. There are so many cool artists up in that neck of the woods, and I’d really love to do that triangle.

Is there anything else you’d like to share for the WMCN blog?

Tristan: We’re getting our records pressed at Outta Wax, which is a Minneapolis-based record label or record-pressing plant. Shout out to Outta Wax. They’re great. We will have a website eventually.

Trevor: Website pushed back six months by the Outlook outage. And the FAA grounding was another thing. 

Toadvine’s music can be found across major streaming platforms. Keep up with them @ toadvine._ on Instagram.

Leave a Comment

WP Radio
WP Radio
OFFLINE LIVE